The deterioration proplems of the wall reliefs of Komir temple, Esna, Egypt
Part of : Mediterranean archaeology & archaeometry : international journal ; Vol.14, No.1, 2014, pages 201-219
Issue:
Pages:
201-219
Author:
Abstract:
The supreme council of antiquities in co-operation with the French mission discovered the Ptolemaic temple of Komir in 1979 in Esna, Upper Egypt. The Ptolemaic temple of Komir was built of regional sandstone and preciously decorated with reliefs and inscriptions. Investigation of the condition of the sites, together with physical, chemical, and mechanical tests of their material revealed that, it is collapsed and only partly preserved and it disposes of some still buried rooms. The Komir temple is exposed to different deteriorations processes caused by internal and external stresses due to the mineral composition of the building materials, climate factors, salts crystallization and groundwater. In this study, the deterioration problems of the wall reliefs were investigated for the aim of its conservation. For this purpose, the building was documented by drawings and photographs. The chemical, physical and structural characterization were performed by means of X-Ray Diffraction (XRD), X-Ray Fluorescence (XRF) and observation of thin section by transmitted light optical microscopy (LOM), polarized microscope, Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM) attached with EDX and thermogravimetric (DTA &TGA). The physical and mechanical properties were done. The results showed that, sandstone is mainly composed of quartz, albite, orthoclase, microcline and dolomite. The density and porosity values of deteriorated sandstone are 1.52 g/cm3 and 25%. Results also showed that the deterioration of stone materials is due to the aggressive action of the environmental agents. Soluble salts, such as chlorides and sulphates were found in efflorescence samples. These results and information allowed the identification of the types of salts and deterioration features may be used in the future for conservation purposes.
Subject (LC):
Keywords:
Sunk reliefs, Komir temple, Ground water, Salt weathering, Excavation
References (1):
- Brai M, Casaletto M.P, Gennaro G, Marrale M, Schillaci, T, Tranchina, L, (2010) Degradationof stone materials in the archaeological context of the Greek–Roman Theatre inTaormina (Sicily, Italy). Applied physics A Materials Science &processing, pp.1-7Charola, AE, Pühringer, J, Steiger, M, (2007) Gypsum: a review of its role in the deteriorationof building materials. Environ Geol., No. 52, 339–352.Colas, E, Mertz J.D, Schneider, C, Barbin,V, Rassineux,,F, (2011) Influence of the clay coatingproperties on the dilation behavior of sandstones, Appl. Clay Sci., pp. 2-26.Dietrich, D, Rosemarie, K (2001) The building stones of ancient Egypt – a gift of its geology.Journal of African Earth Sciences, no.. 33, 631–642.Domsch,K.H, Gams, W, Anderson, T.H, (1980) Compendium of Soil Fungi. Vol. 1-2. London:Academic Press.El-Gohary, M.A, (2010) Investigations on limestone weathering of el-tuba minaret el Mehalla,Egypt: A case study, Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry, Vol. 10, No.1, 61-79.Es-Saghir, M, Dominique V (1979) The discovery of komir temple, preliminary report. In, InstituteFrancais D' Archeologie Oriental (BIFAOC), Tome 83, Cairo, 149-170.Gauri, L. K, Stone (1982) Conservation planning: Analysis of intricate systems, Science andTechnology in Service of Conservation, IIC, London, pp. 4650.Ismail, B, (2001) Weathering process and modes of conservation limestone blocks of Karnaktemples, Luxor, Egypt, Journal of the faculty of archaeology, Cairo University, Vol.4, 25-62.Kamally H.A, (2012) Salt damage on the wall reliefs of Dendera temple, Egypt, econservationmagazine, No. 23, March, pp.57-70Klaus J.H, Norman ,R.W, Frances R, (1988) Consolidation treatment of Massillon (Ohio)sandstone, APT Bulletin, Vol. 20, No. 3, Anniversary Issue, 35-39.Leisen, H, Verbeek, C, Krause, S, (2008) Aspects of conservation in the excavation site of theAthribis temple in Egypt, Environ Geol., No. 56, 689–697.Mack R.C, Grimmer F.A, (2003) Assessing Cleaning and Water-Repellent Treatments for HistoricMasonry Buildings, Washington DC.Maureen, E, Young, D, Urquhart, R, Laing, (2003) Maintenance and repair issues for stonecleaned sandstone and granite building facades, Building and Environment, 38,pp.1125 – 1131.McCabe, S, Smith, B.J, Warke P.A, (2010) Exploitation of inherited weakness in fire-damagedbuilding sandstone, the ‘fatiguing’ of ‘shocked’ stone. Journal of Engineering Geology,N.115, 217–225.Michael, S, Elena Charola, A, (2001) Weathering and Deterioration of stone In stone inarchitecture, properties, durability, 4th edition, Springer Heidelberg Dordrecht, LondonNew York, 227-316.Mahmoud, H, Kantiranis, N, Stratis, J (2010) Salt damage on the wall paintings of the festivaltemple of thutmosis III, Karnak temples complex, Upper Egypt, A case study,International Journal of conservation Science, Volume 1, Issue 3, 133-142.Okafor, N, Ejiofor, M, (1985) The linamarase of Leuconostoc mesenteroides, production,isolation and some properties. J. Sci. Food Agric., 36: 667-678.Polo, A, Cappitelli, F, Brusetti, L, Principi, P, Villa F, Giacomucci L, Ranalli G, Sorlini C, (2010)Feasibility of Removing Surface Deposits on Stone Using Biological and ChemicalRemediation Methods, Environmental Microbiology,1-14.Price C.A, (1993) Preventive conservation of salt-contaminated masonry in the WakefieldTower, HM Tower of London, Institute of Archaeology, Bulletin 30, 121-33.Raper, K, Fennell, B, (1965) The Genus Aspergillus, Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins Company,p. 686Said, R, (1962) The Geology of Egypt, Elsevier New York, p.99.Saleh, S.A, Helmi, F.M, Kamal, M.M, El-Banna, A.E, (1992) Study and consolidation ofsandstone: temple of Karnak, Luxor, Egypt, Studies in conservation, 37,(2), 93-104.Torraca, G, (1981) Porous Building Materials Science for Architectural Conservation,International Centre for the study of the Preservation and the Restoration of CulturalProperty, Rome, pp. 64-66.
