Polybius’ “previous landslide” : proof that Hannibal’s invasion route crossed the col de la Traversette
Part of : Mediterranean archaeology & archaeometry : international journal ; Vol.14, No.2, 2014, pages 77-94
Issue:
Pages:
77-94
Author:
Abstract:
Both Polybius and Livy described a landslide/landslip that blocked the Punic Army’s exfiltration from a high col on the water divide in the Western Alps. The landslide, more aptly termed rockfall, has been a source of contention amongst classicists for centuries despite the fact that only two cols—Clapier and Traversette—exhibit rockfall debris on the lee side of the Alps. While the Clapier rockfall is too small and too young to have provided blockage, the Traversette debris is nearly as Polybius described it when he retraced the invasion route some 60 years after the event. His ‘two-tier’ description of the deposit, a doublet of younger and older rock rubble, including measurements of width and volume are close to modern measurements and prove that he knew, in advance, the route Hannibal had followed. It would take a practiced eye to correctly identify the stratigraphic complexity inherent in the Traversette Rockfall. Here we present weathering ratios, soil stratigraphic, mineral, chemical and microbiological evidence in support of Polybius’ observations as a considerable background database for future geoarchaeological exploration.
Subject:
Subject (LC):
Keywords:
Hannibalic invasion, Traversette Rockfall, physico-mineral-chemical correlation to ancient texts
Notes:
Περιέχει 8 εικόνες και 3 πίνακες.
References (1):
- Ali, A.A., Carcaillet, C., Talon, B., Roiron, P. and Terral, J.-F. (2005) Pinus cembra (arolla), a common tree in the inner French Alps since the early Holocene and above the present tree line: a synthesis based on charcoal data from soils and travertines. Journal of Biogeography, vol. 32, 1659-1669.Bagnall, N. (1999) The Punic Wars. Pimlico, London, 347 pp.Birkeland, P.W. (1999) Soils and Geomorphology, Oxford University Press, Oxford, U.K., 430 pp.Canada Soil Survey Committee (1977) Soils of Canada 1. Agriculture Canada, Ottawa. 243 pp.Carcaillet C. and Muller S.D. (2005) Holocene tree-limit and distribution of Abies alba in the inner French Alps: anthropological or climatic changes? Boreas, vol. 34(4), 468-476.Carcaillet, C., Talon, and B., Barbero, M. (1998) Pinus cembra et incendies au cours de l'Holocène, 300 m au-dessus de la limite actuelle des arbres dans les Alpes du nord-ouest. Écologie, 29, 277-282.Carcaillet, C., Ali, A.A., Blarquez, O., Genries, A., Mourier, B. & Bremond, L. (2009) Spatial variability of fire history in subalpine forests: large and local scale processes during the Holocene (from natural to cultural regimes). Ecoscience, 16(1), 1-12.Connolly, P. (1981) Greece and Rome at War. MacDonald and Co.,Cottrell, L. (1992) Hannibal Enemy of Rome. Da Capo Press, N.Y., 257 pp.David, F. (1995) Vegetation dynamics in the northern French Alps. Historical Biology, vol. 9, 269-295.Day, P. (1965) Particle fractionation and particle size analysis, In, C.A. Black, ed., Methods of Soil Analysis, Madison, Wi., Am. Soc. Agronomy, 545-567.de Beer, G. (1967) Hannibal’s March, Sidgwick and Jackson, London, 164 pp.de Beer, G. (1969) Hannibal. The Viking Press, N.Y., 320 pp.Dodge, T.H. (1891) Hannibal, Houghton Mifflin, N.Y.,Egli, M., Mirabella, A., Sartori, G. and Fitze, P. (2003) Weathering rates as a function of climate: results from a climosequence of the Val Genova (Trentino), Italian Alps, Geoderma, vol. 111, 99-121.Genries A., Muller S.D., Carcaillet C., Mercier L. & Bircker L. (2009) Local-scale processes control spatial variability of subalpine vegetation trajectories during the Holocene. Ecoscience, vol. 16 (1), 13-22.Griffiths, R.I., Whiteley, A.S., O’Donnell, A.G., and Bailey, M.J. (2000) Rapid Method for Coextraction of DNA and RNA from Natural Environments for Analysis of Ribosomal DNA- and rRNA-Based Microbial Community Composition. Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 66(12), 5488-5491.Julig, P., Mahaney, W.C., Kalm, V., Earl-Goulet, J. (2012) Geoarchaeological importance of Subarctic bird perches dated by turf mound accumulation and identified by lichen plumes. Polar Record, doi:10.1017/S0032247412000368.Kalm, V., Kriiska, A. and Aruväli, J. (1997) Mineralogical analysis applied in provenance studies of Estonian Neolithic pottery. — Eesti TA Toimetised. Geoloogia, vol. 1, 16–34.Kuhle, M., and Kuhle, S. (2012) Hannibal gone astray? A critical comment on W.C. Mahaney et al., ‘the Traversetted (Italia) rockfall; geomorphological indicator of the Hannibalic invasion route, Archaeometry, vol. 52 (1), 156-172.Lancel, S. (1999) Hannibal, Blackwell, Oxford, 243 pp.Lazenby, J.F. (1998) Hannibal’s War, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman, 340 pp.Livy, trans. Aubrey de Sélincourt (1972), The War with Hannibal, Penguin, London, U.K, 711 pp.Mahaney, W.C. (1978) Late Quaternary soil stratigraphy in the Wind River Mountains, western Wyoming, In. W.C. Mahaney ed., Quaternary Soils, Geo-Abstracts, Norwich, UK, 223-264.Mahaney, W.C. (1990) Ice on the Equator, Wm. Caxton Ltd., Ellison Bay, Wisc., 386 pp.Mahaney, W.C. (1991) Later Pleistocene and Holocene glacial chronology at Chamonix and Argentière, French Alps. Zeitschrift für Geomorphologie, vol. 35, 225-237.Mahaney, W.C. (2002) Atlas of sand grain surface textures and applications. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK., 237 pp.Mahaney, W.C. (2004) A geological/topographical reconnaissance of Hannibal’s invasion route into Italia in 218 BC. In, D.R. Caldwell, J. Ehlen and R.S. Harmon, eds., Studies in military geography and geology, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, Holland, p. 67-78.Mahaney, W.C. (2008) Hannibal’s Odyssey: environmental background to the alpine invasion of Italia. Gorgias Press, Piscataway, N.J., 345 pp.Mahaney, W.C. (2012) Comments on Kuhle & Kuhle, Archaeometry, ‘Hannibal gone astray’ a critical comment on the Hannibalic invasion route. Archaeometry, doi:10/j.1111/j.1475-4754.2012.00724.x.Mahaney, W.C. and Tricart, Pierre (2008) Hannibal’s debacle in the Combe de Queyras in 218 BC: the unknown Gallic Commander, In Military Geography and Geology: History and Technology, C. P. Nathanail, R.G. Abrahart and R.P. Bradshaw, eds. ISBN number 095477429. Land Quality Management Press, Nottingham, U.K., p. 88-97.Mahaney, W.C., Keiser, L. (2013) Weathering Rinds: Unlikely Host Clasts for Evidence of an Impact-Induced Event. Geomorphology, vol. 184, 74-83.Mahaney, W.C., Milner, M.W., Sodhi, Rana, Dorn R.I., Boccia, S., Beukens, R.P., Tricart, Pierre, Schwartz, Stephane, Chamorro-Perrez, E., Barendregt, R.W., Kalm, Volli, Dirszowsky, Randy W. (2007) Analysis of burnt schist outcrops in the Alps: relation to historical archaeology and Hannibal’s crossing. Geoarchaeology, vol. 22, 797-816.Mahaney, W.C., Kalm, V., and Dirszowsky, R. (2008) The Hannibalic Invasion of Italia in 218 BC: geological/topographic analysis of the invasion routes, In Military Geography and Geology: History and Technology, C. P. Nathanail, R.G. Abrahart and R.P. Bradshaw, eds. Land Quality Management Press, Nottingham University, Nottingham, U.K., p. 76-86.Mahaney, W.C., Kapran, B., Kalm, V., Tricart, P., Carcaillet, C., Barendregt, R.W., and Somelar, P. (2010a) The Traversette rockfall: geomorphological reconstruction and importance in interpreting classical history. Archaeometry, vol. 52, 156-172.Mahaney, W.C., Tricart, P., Carcaillet, C., Blarquez, O, Ali, A.A., P., Agnant, J., Barendregt, R.W., Kalm, V. (2010b) Hannibal’s invasion route: age-old question revisited with new scientific data. Archaeometry, vol. 52, 1096-1109.Mahaney, W.C., Krinsley, D.H., Allen, C.C.R., Langworthy, K., Ditto, J., and Milner, M.W., Weathering rinds: archives of paleoenvironments on Mount Kenya, East Africa (2012), Journal of Geology, vol. 120, no. 6, 591-602.Mahaney, W.C., Keiser, L., Krinsley, D.H., Allen, C.C.R., Dirszowsky, R., and Julig, P. (2013). Weathering rinds as mirror images of palaeosols: examples from the Western Alps with correlation to Antarctica and Mars Journal Geological Society, vol. 170, 838-847.Muyzer, G., de Waal, E.C., and Uitterlinden, A.G. (1993) Profiling of complex microbial populations by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis analysis of polymerase chain reaction-amplified genes coding for 16S rRNA. Applied and Environmental Microbiology, vol. 59(3), 695-700.National Soil Survey Center (NSSC) (1995) Soil Survey Laboratory Information Manual. Soil Survey Investigations Report No. 45. Version 1.00. USDA, Washington, DC., 305 pp.Oyama, M. and Takehara, H. (1970) Standard Soil Color Charts, Japan Research Council for Agriculture and Fisheries.Pech, P., Jomelli, V., Baumgart-Kotarba, M., Bravard, J-P., Chardon, M., Jacob, N., Kedzia, S., Kotarba, A., Raczkowska, Z. and Tsao, C. (2003) A lichenometric growth curve in the French Alps: Ailefroide and Veneon valleys; Massifs des Ecrins. Geodinamica Acta, vol. 16, 187-193.Polybius, trans. Ian Scott-Kilvert (1979) The Rise of the Roman Empire, Penguin, London, U.K., 574 pp.Prevas, J. (1998) Hannibal Crosses the Alps, Sarpedon, Rockville Centre, N.Y., 232 pp.Proctor, Dennis (1971) Hannibal’s March in History, Oxford University Press, Oxford, U.K. 229 pp.Renaud, J.P. (1996) L’itineraire transalpine d’Hannibal. La fin d’une enigma, Archeologia. Prehistoire et Archeologie-Dijon, vol. 324, 48-55.Seibert, J. (1993) Hannibal, Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, Darmstadt, 75-134.Sodhi, R., Mahaney, W.C., and Milner, M.W. (2006) ToF-SIMS applied to historical archaeology in the Alps, Applied Surface Science, vol. 252, 7140-7143.Tricart, P. (1984) From passive margin to continental collision: a tectonic scenario for the Western Alps, American Journal of Science, vol. 384, 97-120.Tricart, P., Lardeaux, J.-M., Schwartz, S., and Sue, C. (2006) The late extension in the inner Western Alps: a synthesis along the south-Pelvoux transect. Bulletin de la Société Geologique de France, vol. 177, 299-310.Whittig, L.D. (1965) X-ray diffraction techniques for mineral identification and mineralogical composition. In Black, C.A., ed., Methods of Soil Analysis, V. 1, Madison, Wisc., Amer. Soc. Agronomy, 671-696.Wilkinson, H. Spencer (1911) Hannibal’s March Through the Alps. Oxford at the Clarendon Press (in a digitized form by internet archive with funding from Microsoft corporation 2007)
