Beyond the archaeological imagination : Observations about Kodjadermen-Gumelnitsa-Karanovo VI architecture based on a study of experimental archaeology
Part of : Mediterranean archaeology & archaeometry : international journal ; Vol.12, No.2, 2012, pages 55-79
Issue:
Pages:
55-79
Section Title:
Articles
Abstract:
The experimental archaeology project presented here aimed at the reconstruction of a dwelling, at the 1:1 scale, belonging to the Kodjadermen-Gumelnitsa-Karanovo VI culture (5th millennium BC), based on archaeological data accumulated from research carried out mainly at the site of Sultana-Malu Roşu (South-East Romania). This reconstruction was followed by the estimation of the volume of materials used for raising the construction in conjunction with the human factor and the time needed for building it. Further, a reconstruction and verification of different techniques for the construction of surface area houses was made. The sources for this project were based on archaeological remains discovered in the field, such as, fragments of walls with impressions of building materials, charred fragments of posts, the size and arrangement of the post holes, and on the indirect information provided by miniature house models of Kodjadermen-Gumelnitsa-Karanovo VI dwellings, which are mostly reflected by ethnographic data. These data were used to verify some of our hypotheses.
Subject:
Subject (LC):
Keywords:
Experimental archaeology, architecture, Eneolithic, Kodjadermen- Gumelnitsa-Karanovo VI
Notes:
Corresponding author: Cătălin Lazăr (lazarc@arheologie.ro), This work was supported by grants of the Romanian National Authority for Scientific Research, CNCS – UEFISCDI, project number PN-II-ID-PCE-2011-3-0982 and project number PN II-RU code 16/2010. We thank Mr. Ciprian Astaloş (University College London, UK) for the translation of the text into English, and Mr. Aurel Mocanu (Manăstirea Village Hall, Călăraşi County, Romania), without whose help this project would not have been possible. We also thank Dr. Radian Andreescu, Dr. Adrian Bălăşescu, Dr. Constantin Haită and Dr. Valentin Radu (National History Museum of Romania) for advice and recommendations, but also for supporting the project. Last, but not least, our gratitude goes to the team who worked in this project (2010- 2011): Vincent Babeş, Alina Filipoiu, Octavian Cazacu, Alexandru Năstase, Cătălin Ivanov, Irina Ionițoiu, Ion Avram, Adela Iacoban, Ciprian Paleacu, Alexandru Buzatu, Mina Barbu ("Ion Mincu" University of Architecture and Urbanism, Bucharest, Romania), Marcian Enache-Poti (The Swedish Trade Council in Romania), Adelina Darie, Mădălina Bolt, Mădălina Voicu, Luisa Fulga, Mihaela Golea, Laura Şendrea, Gabriela Stroe, Vasile Opriş, Diana Mocanu, Alexandru Damian (Faculty of History, University of Bucharest, Romania), Mădălin Chițonu (Department for Culture and National Heritage Mehedinți, Romania), and to the village community who helped with people, ideas and materials.
References (1):
- Andreescu, R., (2001) Sultana, a Unique Site in South-Eastern Europe. In A "Lost" Civilization: Gumelnița, S. Marinescu-Bîlcu (ed.), Institute for Cultural Memory, Bucharest.Andreescu, R. and Lazăr, C., (2008) Valea Mostiştei. Aşezarea gumelnițeană de la Sultana-Malu Roşu. Cercetări arheologice, No. XIV–XV, 55 - 76.Andrieşescu, I., (1924) Les fouilles de Sultana. Dacia, No. I, 51 - 107.Asher, R., (1961) Experimental Archaeology. American Anthropologist, No. 63, 793 - 816.Bailey, D.W., (1990) The Living House: Signifying Continuity. In the Social Archaeology of Houses, R. Samson (ed.), 19 - 48, Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh.Bailey, D.W., (2005) Beyond the meaning of Neolithic houses: specific objects and serial repetition. In (un)settling the Neolithic, D. Bailey, A. Whittle and V. Cummings (eds.), 90 - 97, Oxbow Books, Oxford.Bankoff, H. A. and Winter, F. A., (1979) A house-burning in Serbia. Archaeology, No. 32, 8 -14.Bankoff, H. A. and Winter, F. A., (1982) The Morava Valley Project in Yugoslavia:Preliminary report, 1977–1980. Journal of Field Archaeology, No. 9, 149 - 165.Bem, C., (2001) General Considerations Regarding the Multidisciplinary Archaeological Researches on the Neajlov Valley. In A "Lost" Civilization: Gumelnița, S. Marinescu-Bîlcu (ed.), Institute for Cultural Memory, Bucharest.Bem, C., (2002) A Special Type of Aeneolithic Dwelling. Unicum or Deficiency ofConservation?. Studii de Preistorie, No. 1, 153 - 192.Berciu, D., (1935) Săpăturile de la Petru Rareş. Buletinul Muzeului Județean Vlaşca, No. 1, 1- 55.Blockley, M., (2000) The social context for archaeological reconstructions in England, Germany and Scandinavia. Archaeologia Polona, Vol. 38, 43 - 68.Cavulli, F. and Gheorghiu, D., (2008) Looking for A Methodology Burning Wattle and Daub Housing Structures. A Preliminary Report on An ArchaeologicalExperiment. Journal of Experimental Pyrotechnologies, No. 1, 37 - 43.Chourmouziadis, G. Ch., (1996) the Prehistoric lakeside settlement of Dispilio (Kastoria), Codex, Thessaloniki.Chourmouziadis, G. Ch. and Sophronidou, M., (2007) Dispilio near Kastoria. thePrehistoric Lake Settlement (1992). In Great Moments in Greek Archaeology, P.Valavanis, V. Petrakos and A. Delivorrias (eds.), 272 - 284, Los Angeles.Coles, J. M., (1973) Archaeology by experiment. Hutchinson, London.Coles, J. M., (1979) Experimental archaeology. Academic Press, London.Comşa, E., (1990) Complexul neolitic de la Radovanu. Cultură şi Civilizație la Dunărea de Jos, No. VIII, 5 - 126.Comşa, E., (2000) Cuptoare neolitice din Muntenia. Buletinul Muzeului “teohari Antonescu”, No. 5-6, 93 - 100.Cotiugă, V. and Cotoi, O., (2004) Parcul arheologic experimental de la Cucuteni. In Cucuteni-Cetățuie. Monografie arheologică, M.Petrescu-Dîmbovița and M. C.Văleanu (eds.), 337–351. Bibliotheca Memoriae Antiquitatis XIV, Editura„Constantin Matasă”, Piatra Neamț.Cotiugă, V., (2009) Experimental Archaeology: the Burning of the Chalcolithic Dwellings. In itinera in Praehistoria. Studia in Honorem Magistri Nicolae Ursulescu Quinto et Sexagesimo Anno, Ediderunt, V. Cotiugă, F. A. Tencariu, G. Bodi (eds.), 303–342, Editura Universității “Al. I. Cuza”, Iaşi.Dumitrescu, R., (2011) Construite pentru a arde/“Build to burn”: „note de jurnal” despre o încercare de arheologie experimentală. Studii de Presitorie, No. 8, 235 - 250.Dumitrescu, Vl., (1965) Principalele rezultate ale primelor două campanii de săpături din aşezarea neolitică tîrzie de la Căscioarele. Studii şi Cercetări de istorie Veche, Vol. XVI, No. 2, 215 - 238.Dumitrescu, Vl., Bolomey, Al., Mogoşeanu, F., (1983) Esquisse d’une préhistoire de la roumanie jusqu’á la fin de l’âge du bronze. Editura Ştiințifică şi Enciclopedică, Bucharest.Fahlander, F., (2001) Archaeology as Science Fiction. A Microarchaeology of the Unknown. Kompendiet, Aida Trading AB, Göteborg.Galbenu, D., (1971) Aşezarea neolitică de la Costineşti. Pontica, No. IV, 237 - 245.Gheorghiu, D., (2005) A brief description of the Vadastra Project (2000-2002), Prehistoric archaeology and anthropological theory and education. reports of Prehistoric research Projects, Vol. 6-7, 121 - 123.Gheorghiu, D., (2008) Cultural landscape in the lower Danube area. Experimenting tell settlement. Documenta Praehistorica, No. XXXV, 167 - 178.Gheorghiu, D., (2009) Built to be burnt: the building and combustion of Chalcolithic dwellings in the lower Danube and the Eastern Carpathian areas. InCircumpontica in prehistory: Western Eurasian Studies. in Memory of Eugen Comşa, L. Nikolova, M. Merlini and Al. Comşa (eds.), 55 - 68, BAR Intenrational Series 10144, Archaeopress, Oxford.Ghiță, C., (2008) The Microrelief as Result of Morphohydroclimatic Conditions in Mostistea River Basin. revista de Geomorfologie, No. 10, 103 - 111.Haită, C., (2001) Preparing and Using Construction Materials within the Gumelnița Settlements of Hârşova - Tell and Borduşani - Popină. A Micromorphological Study. In A "Lost" Civilization: Gumelnița, S. Marinescu-Bîlcu (ed.), Institute for Cultural Memory, Bucharest.Hansen, H. -O., (1964) i built a Stone Age house. Phoenix House/John Day co., London and New York.Harsema, O. H., (1982) Structural reconstructions of Iron Age houses in the Netherlands. In Structural reconstruction, approaches to the interpretation of the excavated remains of buildings, P. J. Drury (ed.), 199 - 222. British Archaeological Reports, British Series, 110, Archaeopress, Oxford.Haşotti, P., (1997) Epoca neolitică în Dobrogea. Bibliotheca Tomitana I, Constanța.Isăcescu, C., (1984a) Săpăturile de salvare de la Sultana, com. Mânăstirea, jud. Călăraşi. Cercetări Arheologice, No. VII, 27 - 42.Isăcescu, C., (1984b) Stațiunea eneolitică de la Sultana - com. Mânăstirea. Documente recent descoperite şi informații arheologice, Academia de Ştiințe Sociale şi Politice, Bucureşti, 11-20.Kotsakis, K., (2007) Prehistoric Macedonia. In The History of Macedonia, I. Koliopoulos (ed.), 1 - 22. Museum of the Macedonian Struggle, Thessaloniki.Larsson, L., (1985) Of house and earth: the excavation, interpretation and reconstruction of a late mesolithic house. In in honorem, Evert Baudou, M. Backe et al. (eds.), 197- 210. Archaeology and Environment, Vol. 4, Department of Archaeology, University of Umeå, Umeå.László, A. and Cotiugă, V., (2005) On the Chalcolithic House-Building. Archaeological Observations and Some Experimental Archaeological Data. Studia Antiqua et Archaeologica, No. XXI, 147 - 170.Mareş, I., (1993) Modele din lut ars reprezentând locuințe şi sanctuare eneolitice descoperite pe teritoriul României. Suceava, No. XX, 23 - 42.Marinescu-Bîlcu, S., Popovici, D., Trohani, G., Andreescu, R., Bălăşescu, A., Bălteanu, A. C., Bem, C., Gàl, E., Haită, C., Kessler, E., Moise, D., Radu, V., Tomescu, M., Venczel, M., Vlad, F., Voinea, V., (1997) Archaeological researches at Borduşani-Popină (Ialomița county). Preliminary report (1993-1994). Cercetări Arheologice, No. X, 35 - 143.Marinescu-Bîlcu, S., Andreescu, R., Bem, C., Popa, T., Tănase, M., Bălăşescu, A., Tomescu, M., Haită, C., Tomescu, I., (1998) Şantierul arheologic Bucşani. Campania 1998. Buletinul Muzeului “teohari Antonescu”, No. 2-4, 93 - 113.Marinescu-Bîlcu, S., (2001) Gumelnița culture. In A "Lost" Civilization: Gumelnița, S. Marinescu-Bîlcu (ed.), Institute for Cultural Memory, Bucharest.Mathieu, J. R., (2002) Introduction. In Experimental Archaeology. replicating Past Objects, Behaviours, and Processes, J. R. Mathieu (ed.), 1–11. British Archaeological Reports, International Series 1035, Archaeopress, Oxford.Monah, D., Cotiugă, V. and Cotoi, O., (2005) Construcții experimentale pentru culturile Precucuteni şi Cucuteni. Arheologia Moldovei, No. XXVII, 41 - 58.Morintz, A., (2004) Some Remarks about the Connections Between House Models and Real Houses in Romanian Neolithic. In Prinos lui Petre Diaconu la 80 de ani, I. Cândea, V. Sîrbu and M. Neagu (eds.), 77 - 98, Editura Istros, Brăila.Parnic, V. and Chiriac, D., (2001) Aşezarea eneolitică de la Măriuța. Considerații preliminare asupra habitatului. Cultură şi Civilizație la Dunărea de Jos, No. 16-17, 199-207.Petrescu-Dâmbovița, M., (2001) Eneoliticul dezvoltat. In istoria românilor, vol. i. Moştenirea timpurilor îndepărtate, M. Petrescu-Dîmbovița Al. Vulpe (eds.), 154 - 168, Editura Academiei Române, Bucharest.Popovici, D. and Rialland, Y., (1996) Viața pe malurile Dunării acum 6500 de ani, Paris.Popovici, D., Randoine, B., Rialland, Y., Voinea, V., Vlad, F., Bem, C., Bem, C., Haită, G., (2000) Cercetările arheologice efectuate pe Tell-ul de la Hârşova (jud. Constanța). Cercetări Arheologice, Vol. XI, No. 1, 13 - 123.Popovici, D. (ed.), (2003) Archaeological Pluridisciplinary research at Borduşani-Popină, Editura Cetatea de Scaun, Târgovişte.Popovici, D. (2010) Copper Age Traditions North of the Danube River. In the Lost World of Old Europe. the Danube Valley, 5000-3500 BC, D. W. Anthony, J. Y. Chi (eds.), 91-111, Princeton University Press, Princeton and Oxford.Radunčeva, A., (1976) Vinica - Eneolitno Seliste i Nekropol. Razkopki i proucvanija VI, Balgarska Akademia na naukite, Sofia.Rasmussen, M., (2007) Building houses and building theories – archaeological experiments and house reconstruction. In iron Age houses in flames. testing house reconstructions at Lejre, M. Rasmussen (ed.), 6 - 15. Studies in Technology and Culture, Vol. 3, Lejre Historical-Archaeological and Experimental Centre, Lejre.Reynolds, P. J., (1979) Iron Age Farm: the Butser Experiment. British Museum Publications, London.Reynolds, P. J., (1999) The Nature of Experiment in Archaeology. In Experiment and Design: Archaeological Studies in Honour of John Coles,A. F. Harding (ed.), 156–162, Oxbow, Oxford.Shaffer, G., (1984) Neolithic building technology in Calabria, italy. Ph.D. dissertation, State University of New York, Binghamton.Shea, J. J., Brown, K. S., Davis, Z. J., (2002) Controlled Experiments with Middle Paleolithic Spear Points: Levallois Points. In Experimental Archaeology. replicating Past Objects, Behaviours, and Processes, J. R. Mathieu (ed.), 55–72. British Archaeological Reports, International Series 1035, Archaeopress, Oxford.Simion, D. and Bem, C., (2007) Gumelnița. Bucşani. O nouă lume, acelaşi început, documentary movie, 47 min., Dac Films, Bucharest.Startin, W., (1978) Linear pottery culture houses: reconstruction and manpower. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society, Vol. 44, 143 – 159.Stevanović, M., (1996) the age of clay: the social dynamics of house destruction. University of Berkeley: Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis.Stevanović, M., (1997) The Age of Clay: The Social Dynamics of House Destruction. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology, No. 16, 334 - 395.Şerbănescu, D., (1997) Modele de locuințe şi sanctuare eneolitice. Cultură şi Civilizație la Dunărea de Jos, No. XV, 232 – 251.Ştefan, Gh., (1941) Un nouveau modèle d’habitation de l’éneolithique valaque. Dacia, No. VII-VIII, 93 - 96.Todorova, H., (1974) Kultszene und Housemodell aus Ovčarovo, Bez. Tărgovište. thracia, No. 3, 39 -46.Todorova, H., Ivanov, I., Vassliev, V., Hopf, M., Quitta, H., Kohl, G., (1975) Selistnata mogila pri Goljamo Delčevo. Razkopki i proucvanija V, Balgarska Akademia na Naukite, Sofia.Todorova, H., (1978) the Eneolithic Period in Bulgaria in the Fifth Millennium BC. British Archaeological Reports, International Series, 49, Archaeopress, Oxford.Todorova, H. (ed.), (1982) Kupferzeitliche Siedlungen in Nordostbulgarien. Materialien zur Allegemeinen und Vergleichenden Archäologie 13, Verlag C.H. Beck, München.Todorova, H., Vasilev, V., Janusevic, Z., Kovacheva, M. and Valev, P. (1983) Ovčarovo. Razkopki i Prouchvania IX, Bulgarskata Akademiya na Naukite, Sofia.Todorova, H., (1986) Kamenno-mednata Epokha v Bulgariya. Peto Khilyadoletie predi NovataEra. Izdatepstvo Nauka i Izkustvo, Sofia.Touloumis, K. and Hourmouziadi, A., (2003) The Man and the Lake: Living in the Neolithic Lakeside Settlement of Dispilio, Kastoria, Greece. Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry, Vol. 3, No. 2, 13 - 79.Touloumis, K., (2007) Archaeology and education: six years of archaeology in a Greek high school. the European Archaeologist, No. 26, 13.Viereck, G. S., (1929) What Life Means to Einstein: An Interview. the Saturday Evening Post, 26 October 1929, 17, 110, 113-114, 117.